Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe

If you’re looking for a Halloween party dish that’s both spooky and downright delicious, you’re going to want to try this Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe. It’s quirky, fun, and bursting with flavor—and honestly, I love how it turns out every single time. Whether you’re hosting a kids’ party or an adult gathering, this pasta salad is sure to be the star of the table. So grab your apron, and let’s get spooky in the kitchen!

this Recipe

Ingredients You’ll Need

The ingredients for this Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe are simple, but each one plays a key role in making your salad look Halloween-perfect and taste delicious. I recommend grabbing some quality Italian dressing and the freshest mushrooms you can find; they make such a difference.

• Dry pasta (rotini, cellentani, or favorite shape): Twisty pastas hold onto the dressing and look great in the bowl.
• Water & kosher salt: For perfectly seasoned pasta cooking water.
• Super black gel food coloring: Adds a spooky dark tint to the pasta – a fun touch that kids love!
• White button mushrooms: These become your mushroom skulls; look for firm ones with a nice round cap.
• Butter & olive oil: For browning the mushroom skulls so they get caramelized and flavorful.
• Straw and skewer: Tools to sculpt the mushroom skull eyes and features – simple kitchen finds you might already have.
• Marinated mini mozzarella balls (bocconcini): Small, delicate, and perfect for eyeballs.
• Basil pesto: Fills the mozzarella eyeballs for flavor and color contrast; thin with olive oil if too thick.
• Pitted black olives: The “pupils” of your eyeballs—buy medium or large for ease of sculpting.
• Orange bell pepper: Adds vibrant, spooky shapes cut out with mini cookie cutters.
• Italian dressing: Choose a flavorful one to coat the pasta, but not overpower the delicate mushroom and mozzarella flavors.

Variations

I love customizing this Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe depending on my mood or who I’m serving it to. You can easily swap ingredients or spice it up to make it your own!

• Using Black Bean or Squid Ink Pasta: I discovered this trick to make the pasta even darker and more dramatic—perfect for a gothic Halloween vibe.
• Switch Up the Dressing: Try a spicy Italian or balsamic vinaigrette for more complexity; my family prefers a tangier dressing for contrast.
• Add Protein: I sometimes toss in slices of pepperoni or diced ham to turn this into a hearty main dish that’s still festive.
• Mix Up the Veggies: I’ve swapped orange bell peppers for green or red for more colorful salad interplay; be sure to pick vibrant veggies to keep it eye-catching.

How to Make Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe

Step 1: Craft Your Mushroom Skulls

Start by gently wiping your mushrooms clean with a damp cloth—don’t rinse them under water as they can soak it up and get soggy. Trim the very tip of the stems so you have a clean base. Now the fun part: take a straw and punch out two round eyes on the mushroom caps, then poke corresponding eye holes on the backside. Use a knife tip to make tiny nostrils and slice little “teeth” along the stems. Slice each mushroom in half to create two perfect skull halves. Sauté these cut-side down in butter and olive oil until browned and caramelized—about 3-4 minutes—then flip for another minute. This cooking step breathes life into the skulls with lovely caramelization.

Step 2: Cook Your Pasta with a Spooky Twist

Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil and stir in a bit of super black gel food coloring—you don’t need much to get that Halloween effect. Add your pasta and cook it until just al dente according to package directions. Then, drain and rinse briefly under cold water just enough to stop the cooking and cool it down; be careful not to rinse too long or you’ll wash away the black color. Toss it into a big bowl to cool fully while you move on to the next steps.

Step 3: Assemble Your Mozzarella Eyeballs

Slice your black olives in half lengthwise, then hollow each olive half by using a straw to create a pupil-shaped hole—set these aside carefully. For each mini mozzarella ball (the eyeball), cut a shallow well on the “top” side using a sharp knife. Fill that little divot with basil pesto (thin the pesto with olive oil if too thick). Finally, nestle an olive pupil right into the pesto to complete these creepy yet tasty eyeballs. I like to keep these chilled until assembly to maintain their shape.

Step 4: Cut Out Your Bell Pepper Shapes

Remove the stem and seeds from a large orange bell pepper. Slice it in half and lay flat with the inside facing up. Use mini cookie cutters—stars, triangles, cats, whatever spooky shapes you prefer—to punch out festive pepper pieces. These little vegetable shapes add fun bursts of color and texture to your salad. Save them to toss in last.

Step 5: Toss and Assemble Your Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe

Combine your black pasta, mushroom skulls, and bell pepper shapes in a large bowl. Pour in a good amount of Italian dressing and toss gently so everything gets coated without breaking. Then arrange the mozzarella eyeballs here and there across the salad, gently pressing them into the pasta so they stay put when serving. Serve chilled or at room temperature—both are delicious!

How to Serve Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe

Garnishes

I like to finish off this salad with a sprinkling of fresh basil leaves or a handful of thinly sliced scallions. You can also add a few little red pepper flakes for a subtle kick. It adds a fresh green pop that contrasts beautifully with the dark pasta and creepy eyeballs, and the touch of heat keeps things interesting!

Side Dishes

This pasta salad pairs wonderfully with other Halloween-themed treats like stuffed bell pepper jack-o’-lanterns, garlic bread sticks shaped like bones, or even a simple charcuterie board featuring spooky cheeses and meats. When I serve it for gatherings, I always like to balance the cold pasta salad with something warm and savory on the side.

Creative Ways to Present

For Halloween parties, I love serving this salad inside hollowed-out pumpkins or cauldron-shaped bowls to boost the spooky atmosphere. Another idea I’ve tried is layering the pasta salad in clear glass bowls so the colors and creepy elements like skulls and eyeballs really stand out. These little touches turn a tasty dish into a centerpiece.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I usually store leftover pasta salad in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 2-3 days. I keep the mushroom skulls separate if I have any left to avoid them getting soggy. The mozzarella eyeballs should be stored upright and wrapped carefully to keep their shape and pesto filling intact.

Freezing

Freezing this salad isn’t something I recommend because the mozzarella balls and fresh veggies don’t freeze well—they get watery and lose texture. Instead, plan to enjoy it fresh or within a few days of making it.

Reheating

This pasta salad is best served cold or at room temperature, so reheating isn’t necessary—and honestly, I like it better that way. If you want to bring it slightly up to room temp, just take it out of the fridge about 15 minutes before serving.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Halloween Pasta Salad with Mushroom Skulls and Mozzarella Eyeballs Recipe is one of those dishes that makes you smile when you see it—and the flavor actually delivers, too. I love sharing this at parties because it’s impressive, playful, and super tasty, plus it gives me a chance to show off a little creativity in the kitchen. Honestly, whether it’s for kids, adults, or both, this salad is a festive crowd-pleaser that’s worth every bit of effort. Give it a try at your next Halloween bash—you’ll be so glad you did!

Print